Profenno's Pizzeria & Pub

Located in the heart of Westbrook, ME, Profenno's Pizzeria & Pub is a standout destination for pizza lovers seeking a satisfying blend of classic flavors and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Specializing in traditional Italian-American cuisine, this cozy pizza restaurant and bar invites guests to indulge in hand-crafted pizzas, hearty pasta dishes, and fresh salads—all served in a relaxed setting that feels like a welcoming neighborhood hangout.

The pizza here is undeniably the star of the show. Whether you favor a simple Cheese pizza at $11.50 or prefer to customize with up to five toppings, each pie offers a perfectly baked crust that strikes the ideal balance between chewy and crisp. The unique touch of thinly sliced cheese instead of shredded, paired with modestly sized pepperoni, lends a distinctive character that’s both nostalgic and refreshingly authentic—echoing the best New Jersey-style pies, as noted by longtime customers. Even those with gluten sensitivities will find a flavorful Gluten-Free pizza option, ensuring everyone can join the feast.

Beyond the pizzas, Profenno’s culinary offerings extend to their impressive Pasta Specialties. Indulge in classics like Baked Meat Lasagna ($18.95), rich Fettuccine Alfredo with grilled chicken ($19.95) or garlic shrimp ($21.95), and comforting Parm dishes—Chicken, Veal, Eggplant, and even Haddock—all served alongside perfectly cooked pasta for a hearty, satisfying experience. Their salads, ranging from crisp Garden Tossed to the indulgent Profenno’s Antipasto Salad ($18.95) loaded with salami, capicola, mozzarella, provolone, pepperoni, and marinated veggies, provide refreshing and flavorful accompaniments to any meal.

Stepping inside Profenno’s, you’ll notice the authentic, slightly nostalgic atmosphere that transports you back to a simpler time. The casual yet sincere vibe is enhanced by attentive staff whose heartfelt hospitality is consistently praised—guests frequently mention warm greetings, personalized service, and genuine smiles that make every visit special. This is a place where locals and newcomers alike feel instantly at home, creating a community hub where good food and good company come together effortlessly.

Customer reviews reflect a deep appreciation for the pizza’s quality and flavor, with many comparing it favorably against other local pizzerias. One enthusiastic diner described it as their “newest favorite pizza,” willing to drive from out of town just to savor Profenno’s pies again. Another highlighted the attention to detail—from the well-cooked, non-oily crust to the generous, fresh toppings and a subtle sprinkle of oregano that elevates every slice.

What truly sets Profenno's Pizzeria & Pub apart is its commitment to providing excellent value without compromising taste or quality. Good food here does not come with an exorbitant price tag, making it a beloved spot for families, friends, and pizza aficionados looking for delicious meals that satisfy both palate and wallet.

Whether you're craving a perfectly balanced pizza, a comforting pasta dish, or a refreshing salad, Profenno’s delivers with a care and authenticity that keeps guests coming back time and again. For an approachable yet unforgettable dining experience in Westbrook, this gem is a must-try that makes every visit feel like a flavorful celebration of classic, made-with-love Italian-American cooking.